Return to Answer

The game-recommendation tag applies to any recommendation question, per earlier discussions like http://meta.rpg.stackexchange.com/questions/2711/has-system-recommendation-grown-too-big-for-its-britches. In fact, we changed the tag from system-recommendation to game-recommendation to genericize it.

Note that this guidance is really just a codification of general SE best practices for an edge case where people seem really tempted to ignore them.

As a result, no, personal speculative opinions are not a valid answer. Neither is citing other peoples' personal speculative opinions. Only experience, personal or documented on behalf of someone else, is proper support for a subjective question. I'm not going to bother linking Good Subjective, Bad Subjective again, but read it, it applies to all subjective content on this SE. Of course, where there is objective content (e.g. this generates a higher DPS), that is not subjective and doesn't fall under that requirement.

The game-recommendation tag applies to any recommendation question, per earlier discussions like Has [system-recommendation] grown too big for its britches?. In fact, we changed the tag from system-recommendation to game-recommendation to genericize it.

Note that this guidance is really just a codification of general SE best practices for an edge case where people seem really tempted to ignore them.

As a result, no, personal speculative opinions are not a valid answer. Neither is citing other peoples' personal speculative opinions. Only experience, personal or documented on behalf of someone else, is proper support for a subjective question. I'm not going to bother linking Good Subjective, Bad Subjective again, but read it, it applies to all subjective content on this SE. Of course, where there is objective content (e.g. this generates a higher DPS), that is not subjective and doesn't fall under that requirement.

The game-recommendation tag applies to any recommendation question, per earlier discussions like http://meta.rpg.stackexchange.com/questions/2711/has-system-recommendation-grown-too-big-for-its-britches. In fact, we changed the tag from system-recommendation to game-recommendation to genericize it.

Note that this guidance is really just a codification of general SE best practices for an edge case where people seem really tempted to ignore them.

As a result, no, personal speculative opinions are not a valid answer. Neither is citing other peoples' personal speculative opinions. Only experience, personal or documented on behalf of someone else, is proper support for a subjective question. I'm not going to bother linking Good Subjective, Bad Subjective again, but read it, it applies to all subjective content on this SE.

The game-recommendation tag applies to any recommendation question, per earlier discussions like http://meta.rpg.stackexchange.com/questions/2711/has-system-recommendation-grown-too-big-for-its-britches. In fact, we changed the tag from system-recommendation to game-recommendation to genericize it.

Note that this guidance is really just a codification of general SE best practices for an edge case where people seem really tempted to ignore them.

As a result, no, personal speculative opinions are not a valid answer. Neither is citing other peoples' personal speculative opinions. Only experience, personal or documented on behalf of someone else, is proper support for a subjective question. I'm not going to bother linking Good Subjective, Bad Subjective again, but read it, it applies to all subjective content on this SE. Of course, where there is objective content (e.g. this generates a higher DPS), that is not subjective and doesn't fall under that requirement.