So, if I wanted to ask "What kind of one off games would be ideal for Halloween?", would that be closed as off topic because it is too broad, or maybe because it's too localized in time? What if I were more interested in plots than systems, or the other way around? Duplicate?


1 Answer 1


There are two directions a question like this can go:

1. What features of a game make it a good one to run on Halloween?

This is the more abstract version of the question. The resulting answers will probably contain bits and pieces of a lot of different settings/systems, rather than a concrete "play this" kind of deal.

2. What's a good one off game to run for Halloween?

This would be under the system-recommendations tag, and should follow the usual guidelines.

I'm a little unclear as to what you're asking exactly, but I'll try to give you my take on the individual questions... Let me know if I seem to be missing something.

[...] would that be closed as off topic because it is too broad?

Adding "for Halloween" isn't going to change the on- or off-topic nature of the question. System recommendation questions remain border-line, but generally supported. More abstract questions live or die on the quality of the expression of the question.

What if I were more interested in plots than systems, or the other way around?

Then specify as such in the question body. Perhaps include the settings or adventure tag if your question relates to those areas.


I'm not quite sure what the question is here. In general, if your question is answer by another question (or would be answered by a question that isn't answered yet), it's a duplicate. If it isn't answered, then being explicit about how your question differs will help keep it open.

One final note on Halloween:

There are a lot of different feels associated with Halloween. Off the top of my head, there's soft and fuzzy (candy and jack o' lanterns hooray!); corny (and when they got home and opened the door, they found a hook hanging from the handle! Aaah!); campy (and then the teenagers stuck in the house with the slasher decided to split up...); scary (You know, I don't think I want to go to bed after that last adventure...); or celebrity guest star (ghosts, zombies, vampires, werewolves, oh my).

  • 5
    \$\begingroup\$ What he said. To sum up what I think he said, "make it narrow enough so that you don't get every damn random answer under the sun, like any system-rec question." As you state it, it's too broad, but I assume you didn't really mean that would be the full post. \$\endgroup\$
    – mxyzplk
    Oct 25, 2011 at 20:30
  • \$\begingroup\$ @mxy I'd not stated that explicitly (just linked to the guidelines), but it's a good point to make. \$\endgroup\$
    – AceCalhoon
    Oct 26, 2011 at 15:24

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .