In a comment, I stated explicitly what I wanted to see for my reopen vote.
I wrote a comment right after rolling back the edit:
I've rolled back the edit for now, as iterations of homebrew reviews should be posted as new questions at least 72 hours after the first posting. The details I wanted to see for reopening were answers to NautArch's two comments here and here
The two comments from NautArch were:
Are other players getting homebrew items? If so, can you let us know what those are and what rarity was assigned?
Also, I'm not quite sure I understand the question. Are you asking what the rarity of an item that does all three is, or three separate items? I'm pretty sure it's the former, right?
I rolled back the edit because the revisions were substantive changes to the content in response to the posted answers, which we have a rule against. I then left a comment stating explicitly what I wanted to see out of the question before reopening. So I'm not sure this is accurate:
I suspect we're doing the author a disservice here in not making it clear what we actually expect from them.
My comment was clear and asked explicitly for some concrete information.