I answered this question. The OP clearly disagrees with my answer (or maybe just wishes the answer were different). I've encouraged him to post an opposing answer if he disagrees, but he seems to want to just argue with me in the comments, or add more content to his original question, in the hopes of convincing me to change my answer. He's going around in circles at this point, so there is nothing new that is going to convince me to change my answer.
In this situation, should the OP be encouraged to post an opposing answer?
What's the "right thing" (if there is one) for the OP to do in a situation like this, according to this site's culture? (I know it's not arguing in the comments...)