I am a bit confused about what to do with my question Optimizing Torso/Body slot when restricted to light armor, no metal with high WIS.
I was expecting the answerers to suggest cool items existing in the books for the torso/body slot with specific properties that you can't get with the standard magic item creation rules. Instead of that, the two answerers focused almost uniquely on those rules and uniquely for amors, while my mood was more like "Ok, except if there exists an exceptional armor especially fitted for the situation, they probably will suggest me good vests or robes".
While I enjoyed reading their suggestion about using an alternative material similar to mithral, I can't really accept it because even if it is technically legal by RAW, it breaks the spirit of the rule:
Her ethos requires a certain vulnerability that allows her to more fully empathize with those in their care
So the matter is not about not being able to using metal in which case using a material with similar properties would be ok. The matter is about keeping a certain vulnerability. So from my point of view I can't accept any of the answers. But the two people who answered already helped me a lot in the past with other questions I asked and I don't want to direspect them. Plus since english is not my mother language, I think I might have not used the good words to express the question I had in mind.
So what should I do now?
- Edit the question?
- Accept one answer and ask another question?
- Other possibility?