... a text-based online game created in 1988? Or strictly tabletop paper & pencil games?

From what I can see, there has been general discussion regarding online text-based games there. However what I am not seeing are any prominent tags dedicated to any one online MUD.

My question is simply this: if a community of text-based (online) RPG'ers were looking for a closely-moderated stack to seek answers regarding aforementioned game mechanics & such, would RPG be an appropriate place to do so?


2 Answers 2


Arqade, the gaming SE, is probably a better option

I briefly looked over the New Player's Guide on the Gemstone IV Wiki, and while it does have quite a lot of elements that are similar to a table-top RPG, I think it fits the mold of "video game" more closely than it fits "table-top RPG". While this site does address RPGS that are played over the internet, using services like play-by-post or tabletop simulators, Gemstone IV has much more of a video game system surrounding it. Moreover, I think discussions of (programmed, non-social) game mechanics decidedly do not belong here.

That being said, role-playing questions are welcome here

Based on the discussion in this meta post, questions about roleplaying that relate to the social, non-video-game aspects of Gemstone IV would be welcome here. I think that such questions will have to be evaluated on a case-by-case basis, and would be generally a bit controversial, but it really depends on the type of questions you want to ask.

Give it a try!

I think that you should go ahead and give it a shot. If the community doesn't like it, it will be closed and the question will disappear, with no lasting harm done. I can certainly imagine some possible questions that would be within the scope of the site, so there's some nonzero chance that your question will be accepted here.

  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ These are all certainly excellent answers. This is a tough one for me, as I have played this game on and off for nearly twenty years. There is an inherently strong social aspect, but you are correct in that there are also many NPC aspects to the game that would be better discussed on Arquade or on the existing game forum. Thank you for the clarification. \$\endgroup\$
    – Eodus
    Commented Mar 4, 2017 at 7:11

This site is for RPGs, games where a number of players get together and engage in a group activity that creates an emergent story (though the story may not necessarily be the focus of the activity).

CRPGs (computer RPGs) are not usually RPGs in that traditional sense. It is possible to play an RPG meeting this site's definition of RPG through the medium of a CRPG. Questions about the RPGing part of such an activity would be on-topic. However, questions about the video-gamey CRPG aspects would not be.

So, for example, if you run a MUD server to emulate a West Marches style campaign and modify the game as needed to interact with your players' exploration and you want to ask about, e.g. how to build suspense or deal with imbalance between characters in a party or whatever that would be on-topic. If your players wanted to ask what to do about their jerk server admin nerfing anyone who interferes with the plans of his GMPC, that would be also be on-topic.

However, if you wanted to ask about what mobs are located in such-and-such a region, or more generally speaking, if you wanted to ask any question not having to do with a hack of the game turning it into an RPG, those questions would be off-topic.

  • \$\begingroup\$ So essentially questions relating to the social elements of the game would be acceptable. However, elements relating to the mathematics or other functional aspects behind the game itself would not be acceptable? \$\endgroup\$
    – Eodus
    Commented Mar 4, 2017 at 7:02
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ @FurryWombat sort of. If the game became predominantly used as an RPGing device and popular enough, eventually the latter questions would also be on-topic. The social elements are also only on-topic if you are using the game to RPG. Gemstone seems pretty RPG-centric, so it's probably okay to ask about the social stuff. \$\endgroup\$ Commented Mar 4, 2017 at 7:19

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .