Questions tagged [game-recommendation]
For questions on meta about game recommendation questions. (NOTE: Game recommendation questions are no longer allowed on RPG.SE.)
42
questions
-8
votes
1answer
139 views
Community Cleanup Duty: Game Recommendations
There are still QUITE some questions out there that are game recommendation questions and not closed or locked.
It might take months to go and close and lock them all by hand, especially since game ...
11
votes
3answers
278 views
Is this question about a site listing absurdly powerful D&D 3e/3.5e characters really a recommendation question?
I have stumbled upon this question: Site with absurdly powerful characters for D&D 3/3.5. It asks about a site that the querent has seen.
The question does not ask the users to suggest a game, not ...
7
votes
3answers
149 views
Is it good to use a Q&A to help other users discover a system?
I'm currently playing a campaign of the game "Wasteland : Terres Gâchées", a french RPG, and I was wondering how could I help people (mostly french, as there is for now no English version) know it, as ...
7
votes
1answer
134 views
Can we clarify Game Recommendation/Shopping questions further?
I recently wanted to ask a question to see if something was possible RAW in any published RPG systems. It was eventually put on hold as Off Topic - Game Recommendation, and I proceeded to try to edit ...
1
vote
2answers
100 views
I really don't think this question on how to get feedback on homebrew material was a shopping question
So, I realize we don't actually have a consensus definition of what a recommendation question is at this point, but bear with me.
A question was asked recently about how to get feedback on a homebrew ...
5
votes
2answers
261 views
What actually is a shopping question?
In the What makes my Pathfinder question off-topic, while the same 3.5e question is allowed to stay? discussion the problem turned out to be that some members treat my question as a shopping question. ...
7
votes
3answers
252 views
Can we respond to a closed recommendation question by self-answering another question?
Recommendations of games that fit desired criteria are off topic at RPG.se for established reasons (mostly: it breaks voting and everyone has an opinion they must add to the list).
Earlier today a ...
6
votes
1answer
50 views
Questions tagged [game-recommendation] still show the old banner
Questions tagged game-recommendation on the main site appear to still get the banner defined in another meta question saying
As this is a game-recommendation question, please adhere to the FAQ, the ...
11
votes
1answer
194 views
I want to ask for recommendations, but that's off topic. Is there any way to ask my question?
Recommendation questions have been off-topic since August 2015. If I need a recommendation, how can I get help now?
Return to the FAQ Index
3
votes
1answer
57 views
Changing the tag description for game-recommendation
Given that game-rec questions are no longer on-topic for the site, should we change the tag description to make this clear? At the moment, its existence with a full description gives the impression ...
10
votes
2answers
459 views
The policy change regarding game-rec questions needs review
A recent meta post about the efficacy of game-rec questions, which had the initial tone of "How are we doing with this question type?" became a tacit vote to ban the question type.
This is ...
19
votes
0answers
2k views
Are Game Recommendation Questions On Topic, Revisited
Game recommendation questions are sadly NOT on topic here on RPG.SE.
This means the following kinds of questions are off topic:
I want to play (details) kind of game/story. What game should I use to ...
3
votes
2answers
60 views
Are the game-rec guidelines strictly equivalent to GS/BS?
GS/BS applies to everything subjective all the time across all stack exchanges and is one of our most frequently linked posts, to the point that we have a highly supported proposal to get a shortcut ...
4
votes
3answers
158 views
Do the Game-Rec Guidelines apply to all of the kinds of recommendation questions?
Game recommendation applies to both the recommending of games and the recommending of products for games, such as tools. The recommending of game systems in particular is the basis for our game-...
17
votes
9answers
841 views
Community self-evaluation: How are we doing with game recommendations?
Our game recommendation guidelines are four years old this month. It's worth taking some time to reflect and review as a community how well they are working.
What works well? What doesn't? Have they ...
2
votes
2answers
150 views
"Grim & gritty" in game recommendations
From What's a good system for a short adventure / one-shot in Westeros:
The players should play lowborns, so grim and gritty rules would match my thoughts quite well
What is required to ...
11
votes
2answers
187 views
Game-rec and designer intent
Should citations of designer intent alone be sufficient for a valid answer to game-recommendation questions? That is, in the absence of any description of actual play experience?
10
votes
3answers
245 views
Voluntary banners for game-rec answers
I have an idea to improve our answers to game-recommendation questions, and I'm presenting it here as an optional, voluntary practice that community members might wish to adopt: voluntary banners at ...
13
votes
2answers
279 views
Two Answers - One Deleted - What's the difference?
My answer to this question was deleted. Another answer, similar to mine (no actual experience w/ Harry Potter setting, experience w/ campaign similar to the one described), remains.
What's the ...
10
votes
3answers
361 views
How do we handle "game survey" questions?
Recommended reading:
Are game recommendation questions on topic?
How to deal with questions that just don't understand the scope of the RPG landscape?
What's so problematic about a ...
5
votes
1answer
81 views
How to narrow down game-recommendation questions?
How to deal with questions that just don't understand the scope of the RPG landscape? covers the (somewhat persistent) problem we have with game-recommendation questions, and what members of the ...
11
votes
2answers
134 views
Accepting an answer on a game-recommendation question
I've recently started a game-recommendation question and have received some very good suggestions from the community. I'm ready to try a few of them, but there's a more immediate problem that needs ...
8
votes
1answer
116 views
Overly broad game recs are being reopened and left open
I’ve noticed a pattern in game-recommendation questions recently:
Someone posts an incredibly broad game recommendation question.
It gets swiftly closed as too broad
The asker protests and adds a ...
8
votes
0answers
41 views
Allow the community to attach the game-rec post notice or tie it directly to the tag
So we have a post notice now for game-rec questions. That's great, there's just one problem.
Only 3 people on this site are capable of applying it.
This request is for one of two things, either:
...
5
votes
2answers
88 views
How should we deal with game-recs now that we have a notice?
We now have this notice that can get added to our game-recommendation questions. An example is this question.
As this is a game-recommendation question, please adhere to the FAQ, the rules for ...
8
votes
2answers
200 views
RPG hacks as answers to game recommendation questions
I sometimes see some of the ever problematic game recommendation questions having very specific requirements. And sometimes, I don't see a game I know answering those requirements, but I see how ...
19
votes
3answers
623 views
What's so problematic about a recommendation question having potentially hundreds of answers, anyway?
This Q&A is out of date - game-recs are now off topic, see Are Game Recommendation Questions On Topic, Revisited
We've recently had a couple of recommendation questions appear with requirements ...
18
votes
3answers
289 views
Let's make [game-recommendation] actually be for recommendations of games
We should split game-recommendation up and make it just be for actual recommendations of games. This has come up before, but hear me out, because we only need to create one extra tag to offload all ...
33
votes
4answers
518 views
Permanent banner for game-recommendation tag
On every question (correctly) tagged with game-recommendation, somebody comes along and leaves a comment reminding answer's how to address the question properly. To make this more permanent than the ...
7
votes
2answers
164 views
Query over mod closing of question of 'poor reader' question
I am confused as to why this question has been closed...
Are there any RPGs that a first grade reader can read and learn?
...with comments added by mods for answers to show how they have experienced ...
1
vote
3answers
91 views
Can we add an adventure-recommendation tag?
I was looking through the published-adventure tags looking for some insights on modules to run. However I was getting a lot of questions that were just noise for me.
I would like to propose adding ...
7
votes
2answers
207 views
What are our good game-req questions?
Just so we have some stats on the thing, which game-recommendation questions (or other shopping questions) would you all classify "good", "of value", and "answered well."
I'm trying to get a sense ...
3
votes
2answers
99 views
How should we handle near-duplicates in system recommendation questions?
So, part of the Stack Exchange philosophy is that the question should suggest clear criteria for judging an answer, and ought to be relevant to a real problem the poster is experiencing.
With system ...
6
votes
1answer
130 views
For a System Recommendation question, is it better to give one answer suggesting multiple systems or one answer per system?
I wrote three answers to Are there any good tabletop RPGs for young beginning players. I made it three answers instead of one so that they could be voted on individually. (I could swear that, at the ...
6
votes
1answer
119 views
Appropriate Answers for System Recommendation Questions
I have been a little leery of responding to system recommendation questions for a while now. Per my understanding of the FAQ, I only respond to them when I know my recommendation will be a solid fit ...
17
votes
9answers
478 views
Has [system-recommendation] grown too big for its britches?
We occasionally get adventure/encounter/setting/campaign recommendation questions that are asking for a subjective evaluation, not just objectively-identifiable features. They're infrequent enough ...
2
votes
1answer
61 views
Tag system recommendation questions with the systems that get recommended?
Just a thought to make the site perhaps more useful to future users who search, could we make it standard practice to edit system-recommendation questions (the good ones, I mean) to include tags for ...
6
votes
5answers
132 views
What should our pro-forma system-recommendation comment be?
Given that we're gearing up for a default comment, let's get some community input on what the best comment for describing our sys-req questions should be.
I'll post some of the ones we've used as ...
11
votes
0answers
115 views
Can we have a post notice for system-recommendation questions?
RPG has long allowed system-recommendation questions under fairly tight tight rules, and every time they pop up the mods are posting a general comment like the following:
Just a note folks, ...
4
votes
1answer
153 views
Why are some system recommendation questions being closed while others are not?
Are there any other Beer & Pretzel PnP games along the lines of Paranoia? has been closed twice now, but RPG designed for irregular players/gaming? is still open. Can someone explain to me what ...
45
votes
1answer
6k views
Are game recommendation questions on topic? [duplicate]
This Q&A is out of date - see the new answer (no) in Are Game Recommendation Questions On Topic, Revisited
Many Stack Exchange sites, like the similar gaming.SE, do not allow game recommendation ...
2
votes
1answer
106 views
Is "Game for X" subjectivity bait and can it be helped? [duplicate]
Possible Duplicate:
Are game recommendation questions on topic?
There's a specific kind of question that I would like to see get a little guidance here, because I see it abused so badly on forums....