Questions tagged [specific-question]
For questions primarily concerned with or seeking guidance for an individual site question.
234
questions
4
votes
1answer
116 views
Can this question on real-world corollaries to Forgotten Realms civilizations be salvaged?
I asked this question: Are any of the kingdoms/realms of the Forgotten Realms based on real world civilisations?
It was closed for asking about Designer Intent, which is off topic.
I've run into pages ...
6
votes
1answer
90 views
Why was my answer to a question about the naming of oozes deemed “not an answer”?
I recently answered the question What's the difference between a jelly, a pudding, and other oozes? by saying that there is no answer to discover. However, my answer was deleted. That's fine in ...
10
votes
1answer
145 views
Are these three questions on gemstone size and value duplicates?
How big is a 5,000gp diamond?
and
How big is a gemstone in the dmg gemstone table?
and
How big is a 50 gp diamond?
These three very related questions are potentially a triplet of duplicates. Rather ...
15
votes
1answer
206 views
I asked a bad question, how should I fix that?
The question I am talking about is this question about the telepathic range of a familiar previously summoned by Find Familiar while a Flock of Familiars spell is active by the same caster.
Now, the ...
9
votes
2answers
129 views
How should we handle this question that refers to information that's likely to change over time?
I'm curious specifically about the question What is the order in which published D&D 5e adventures should be played?, which listed the published D&D 5e adventures available at the time the ...
11
votes
3answers
268 views
Is this question about a site listing absurdly powerful D&D 3e/3.5e characters really a recommendation question?
I have stumbled upon this question: Site with absurdly powerful characters for D&D 3/3.5. It asks about a site that the querent has seen.
The question does not ask the users to suggest a game, not ...
8
votes
1answer
344 views
Why was this answer to the question “Can a player choose to fail a spell's ability check contest?” deleted?
The question Can a player choose to fail a spell's ability check contest? has a deleted answer. For users without 10k rep, here's a screenshot of the answer:
While the post score is very negative,...
2
votes
3answers
219 views
Should this question on bludgeoning damage attacks with other stat scores be closed?
This question has gone through several rounds of open/close and it's unclear to me what the status to be.
I had the first comment to the question asking for a better understanding of the bounds ...
2
votes
2answers
154 views
Why was this question that has a lot of community disagreement reopened without community discussion?
This question on bludgeoning damage with a different stat went through a couple rounds of community closure and reopening.
But then it was closed again, and then reopened by a single user (mod) rather ...
6
votes
1answer
143 views
Was my edit to this answer on a Q&A about Spell Sniper an edit too far?
I recently made a substantial edit to this answer to the Q&A "Which spells benefit from the Spell Sniper feat?", that would make a good dupe target.
The help page on editing says:
Edits ...
7
votes
2answers
185 views
I got several good answers and a best answer, so I'm good - but should I put work into getting my closed question reopened?
I asked the following question: How do you determine what action belongs to who in a modernist GM-based game?
I got an answer out of it and even some upvotes, and I don't really want or need anything ...
8
votes
4answers
441 views
Should this question about “the Wildemount Chronugy subclass ability chronal shift” be tagged as D&D 5e without OP specifying it?
Straight-forward: this question has caused an edit war and a close-reopen-close war. The argument for tagging and reopening is:
The splat book only exists in DnD-5e, so it's not guessing – Pureferret
...
5
votes
2answers
93 views
Is a question asking for a resource list of places to find developer commentary on the construction of D&D 5e's rules on-topic and wanted?
We have the following relevant Meta Q&A which covers the topicality of asking for commentary on specific rules (they are currently considered off-topic):
Are questions about rule intent on topic?
...
4
votes
1answer
96 views
Should a mechanic-specific question that becomes ultimately about GMing be retagged?
My answer to this question about balancing combat powers has reframed it to be about being a new DM with new players.
I've said why it's a bad idea in general, I've given some advice, but not answered ...
8
votes
3answers
335 views
Question closure: Why does a round last 6 seconds?
I recently asked Why does a round last 6 seconds? on the main site.
To the best of my experience, this question is on-topic, specific, answerable, and reasonably scoped.
Nevertheless, it was closed as ...
16
votes
2answers
376 views
Getting a straight answer from questions filled with frame challenges
On the question How to create a villain for level 1 players, there are many great answers, however they are all frame challenges. They don't help someone who needs to actually create a conventional ...
4
votes
3answers
185 views
Can this question about homebrewing potentially be reopened?
My question here concerns the following closed question about homebrewing a monster for D&D 5E.
help in adapting a monster from a short story to 5E
My understanding of the reasons for closure
It ...
1
vote
0answers
71 views
Would this question about when it's better for a Pact of the Chain warlock to have their familiar attack be an on-topic bounded list question?
Recently, I asked this question: For a Pact of the Chain warlock, is choosing to have their familiar attack generally the worse option for the warlock's action?
As I mention at the end of the ...
13
votes
2answers
428 views
Does adding the system tag to this question violate the “never guess the system” policy?
This question: Would Zorquan be a Unity domain patron?
As I said in a comment, given that the question includes "2e Forgotten Realms" (provided for background context for lore purposes) and "we're ...
5
votes
1answer
158 views
Advice for getting this question about the overseer's major creation reopened
The question "In this situation, what are the best tactical uses for at-will major creation?" seems complete except for perhaps needing more information about the environment in which the final ...
2
votes
1answer
101 views
Isn't my question about LARP opinion-based?
Two years ago, I asked a question: How do I get my players' LARP characters to not be a bunch of murderous cretins?
It was about a problem that most Russian LARPers know about, a very practical ...
-2
votes
3answers
163 views
Can my question about what D&D 5e build can summon all summonable monsters with the fewest possible levels be reopened?
My question is here: What DnD 5e build (with minimum number of combined levels over all classes) is needed to summon all summonable monsters?
I do not believe my question needs any changes.
The ...
3
votes
1answer
116 views
What should we do with these two questions on knowing if Charm is cast on someone when spell fails?
A question was recently asked about whether a target of charm who made their save would know that a spell was cast on them.
I had found the this question which includes that case of the new question ...
6
votes
1answer
180 views
Should I narrow down this particular question about combat without opportunity attacks, or leave it as broad as it is?
Here's the question — How would combat work without opportunity attacks? It virtually asks "why games need opportunity attacks and what happens if we remove them".
It was asked in context of D&D ...
2
votes
1answer
127 views
How should I handle my question about whether hearing is useful in spotting a hiding creature?
I wanted to ask a question that goes against something that some (many? a lot? most?) DMs believe. I thought it would be best to be clear and thorough in explaining why I came to the conclusion I did, ...
2
votes
1answer
106 views
Can we slow down with the “when did X appear and how did they differ between editions” style questions?
There's now four on the top page:
Artificers
Druids
Rangers
Warlocks
The first line of the help page states:
You should only ask practical, answerable questions based on actual problems that you ...
5
votes
1answer
84 views
When should we apply the [targeting] tag?
targeting can be a very general tag, because basically nearly every spell/attack etc. involves a target.
Should we only be applying targeting when the querent specifically mentions targeting? Or is ...
3
votes
1answer
95 views
Star Wars Lore: a Request for Explanation, and Either Migration or Reopening
I've had this question about sources for price benchmarks for typical items/services closed as off-topic. I would like to request either one of two actions, or an explanation of the logic behind what ...
4
votes
1answer
101 views
A dupe target with an incomplete answer: is this dupe designation mistaken?
One of our users has asked a question about the PHB+1 rule in Adventurers League(AL), but is specifically asking about some ambiguity regarding season 9 sources.
The title looks like it fits another ...
9
votes
3answers
177 views
How do we help this new user formulate a question about their homebrew Toadstool that can be properly answered?
A new user has posed this homebrew review question, which has gone through a ton of edits and is seemingly in a rollback war between users:
How would a major buffing ability effect challenge rating?
...
2
votes
1answer
54 views
Is this question about invisibility a list question?
It turned out that there are multiple 1st-level abilities that make their user invisible, and that's why this question has 3 answers as of now, all of them showing a way to get invisibility at level 1....
7
votes
1answer
145 views
Would asking for a comparison of 4e warlock pacts with 5e warlock patrons be primarily opinion-based?
I was planning on asking the following question:
Does each warlock pact type from 4e have an equivalent in 5e?
I know little of 4e, but am familiar with 5e. I know there are various types of pact in ...
-10
votes
3answers
261 views
Closing a question based on the Moderators' belief about what the answer will be
A common issue I've seen on stackexchange in general, and which appears to have happened here on rpg.se, is a question is closed because the moderators imagined they knew what the answer would be and ...
38
votes
1answer
493 views
I think this answer might be harmful
This answer currently suggests swimming while wearing a full suit of metal armor would be a reasonable thing to do in real life. In actuality, jumping into water with a full suit of metal armor on ...
10
votes
2answers
344 views
Was this question closed because it was about realism/verisimiltude?
Was this question closed because it was about realism/verisimiltude? Or some other reason(s)?
Is it possible to wield a 'greatsword'?
Not that it's a great question, or isn't easily ...
11
votes
1answer
231 views
I want to ask about methods of incorporating errata into a rulebook, but I'm not sure of its subjectivity
I want to ask something like the following question, but am unsure of its framing:
How do you track/incorporate errata in relation to printed rulebooks without having to memorize, or constantly check ...
1
vote
1answer
65 views
How else can I improve this question about PC-tailored homebrew?
The question: Does PC-tailored homebrew require special considerations?
My first draft was written poorly and I fully understand why it was closed so fast. Now I believe I addressed all the issues ...
6
votes
1answer
262 views
How should we deal with these multiple related questions about weapons used for Extra Attack/Two-Weapon Fighting?
There are a number of D&D 5e questions specifically asking about what weapons can be used when making multiple attacks using the Extra Attack feature, the Two-Weapon Fighting rule, or both:
Can ...
5
votes
2answers
105 views
Why is this question about which build is optimized for damage too broad?
My question: Which of these builds is best optimized for damage?
I am wondering about the amount max average damage each of my suggested builds could put out each turn. This seems like a math ...
3
votes
0answers
141 views
Is this question on helping to pick the CR of an animal companion in a homebrew class stackable?
This question on What CR dragon companions would make the damage output of my ranger archetype balanced? seems like it may not be a good question for the stack in it's current form. But it also seem ...
2
votes
1answer
113 views
This question shouldn't be closed/looking for reopen voters
In D&D 5e, is it at all possible to create half-subclasses? is closed as Too Broad. It's not. It's also not unclear or opinion-based. It could benefit from better wording, especially in the ...
8
votes
2answers
219 views
How should these questions about temporary hit points/Armor of Agathys (that are currently marked as duplicates) be handled?
This meta question was prompted by the following 3 questions on mainsite (mainly the first two):
Do multiple sources of Temporary Hit Points combine or do you only get one set?
How does Armor of ...
2
votes
2answers
281 views
Question Workshop: Are the new Bard Class Options Tier 1
I tried to ask a question, but it was closed as opinion based. The version of the question at time of writing is given here:
The tiers as defined here https://1d4chan.org/wiki/Tier_System
Tier 1: ...
5
votes
1answer
210 views
Is this character optimisation question I have 'stackable'?
Character optimisation is not normally my thing. Is the following character optimisation question appropriate for main-site? Are my goals specific enough? If not, how could I improve it?
One of my ...
-3
votes
1answer
221 views
Around and around we go. Hexadin vs. battle smith question closing
Another question closed unnecessarily, another question we need to drag into meta to save it. This time we have Can you compare and contrast a Battle Smith Artificer vs a Paladin with a single dip in ...
8
votes
1answer
141 views
Should something be done about the current duplicate statuses of these related questions on readied actions?
The three following questions currently exist (ordered from newest to oldest):
If I Ready an action, can I then use my reaction for something else?
Reaction while holding a readied action?
Can you ...
3
votes
2answers
99 views
Should I change this question to something more generic?
This question and answer about Pathfinder 2 generated a lot more upvotes than I expected.
I guess because it accidentally highlights a big difference between Pathfinder 1 and 2, namely in 2 you do not ...
5
votes
1answer
169 views
What should we do about these two duplicate questions?
I just came across this question:
What determines whether a magic item requires attunement?
which reminded me of a question I answered:
How can I decide if my homebrew item should require ...
3
votes
1answer
87 views
Request that these questions about Warlock spell slots and multiclassing gain a second duplicate
There currently exist both of the following questions:
Can I cast a Warlock spell with another (higher) spell slot from a different multiclass?
What level are spells cast at if a warlock multiclasses ...
4
votes
1answer
89 views
Are these questions about damage reduction when multiple damage types are involved duplicates?
Recently this question was bountied:
What part of a multi-type damage roll is reduced by a non-type-specific effect?
And earlier today I found this question:
How does a Battle Master's Parry ...
