New answers tagged closed-questions
-1
I think another reason that realism questions should be off-topic, in addition to those stated by doppelgreener, is that allowing realism questions will leave us open to many unanswerable questions. Imagine a realism question comes up in a system like GURPS. GURPS has a strong focus on realism. The question is about a specific rule that seems to be ...
21
This question is what we call a real-world research question. This is mentioned in our on-topic help article:
Generic real-world topics
Questions about a general real-world topic such as history, geography or economics, whilst relevant to RPGs, may be off topic if they are not RPG-centric (or better belong on another Stack Exchange site, such as ...
1
Your questions could do with more focus
It's a hard question to answer. Generally homebrew is most balanced when it is most similar to existing content. There are certainly a lot of situational and niche content which is balanced. With regards to complexity, there are some complex class features, most tend to be 1 or 2 sentences but there are some with as ...
6
It's worth noting that, when your question was closed, it was lacking a lot of detail. "Why was it closed" is not the same as "can it be reopened". I can't say for certain why your question was closed, as I was not one of the users that voted to close it. The listed close reason usually isn't too informative, so I'll recommend not focusing too much on the "...
7
I think your question is too broad it is because you're asking too many things at once, and haven't defined it in a way to have a singular meaningful, useful answer.
You're asking what the optimized damage for three different builds are. On top of that, you're asking for average DPR as well as maximum single turn damage (which I assume you mean this by ...
3
I would say reopen #1 and leave #2 and #3 as is. I believe you were correct with your interpretation as mentioned in the "rereading" paragraph. However #3 is attempting to clarify if the damage from AoA is only valid with the THP granted by AoA or if it works with any THP.
2
I'm not sure
If the question is simply asking Can I homebrew this, then yeah, it's answerable and should be reopened.
If it's asking Can I homebrew this and remain balanced, that's also possibly answerable by someone who has done it, but it also seems to potentially be a shopping question at that point as it's also potentially Has someone done this and can ...
1
I think it should be left as-is. The answer to #2 is correct for #1 and for #3.
Top 50 recent answers are included
