16

None of these. “Does a Water Elemental freeze when kept below 0°C?” is super inadvisable: Dungeons & Dragons is not a physics or chemistry simulator, and you're almost always going to run into trouble when trying to treat it like one. Also, #2 would definitely not be okay—see When a Question Changes Completely, Should it be a New Question? which suggests ...


16

The system is utterly clear and we should add it András has been asking PF2e questions lately, and this question even links to material from that system. This is extremely similar to questions linking to D&D Beyond. The system is undeniably clear and András clearly knows how the site works and just forgot to add the tag (I have done this myself as well ...


13

Leave it closed until the querent's goals are clearer. The question has been closed at least twice for being unclear. The question has undergone some minor edits but the fundamental confusion is still there. There are currently 11 answers (and several now-deleted answers) that cover a variety of possible solutions. It is unclear why none of them suffice for ...


11

The questions are old enough at this point that changing them invalidates their answers These questions are from May 5th, 10th, and 11th. It is now an entire month later and these questions have meaningful answers that work under the assumption that these questions are actually about the fifth edition of Dungeons & Dragons. Thus these questions are ...


10

It should be closed with further details needed, because it's not a system-agnostic question. System matters for understanding the problem and understanding what solution to apply. Factors that the system influences include but are not limited to: What actual qualities do the “exotic” or “normal” races have that would have a player gravitate toward or away ...


9

The system is clear and we should add it I recently got the Eldritch Maul tattoo from Tasha's Cauldron of Everything and I also have the Insignia of Claws. These both add a +1 modifier to my unarmed attack would these stack? Is there any system with something that could called an "Eldritch Maul tattoo" that comes from something called "Tasha'...


8

On further thought, your question is not a duplicate You ask: Let's say I craft a Page of Limited Wish [...] Would this allow me to cast Limited Wish? I have a spell slot of the appropriate level (higher, even), and I have the page to make the spell "known" to me. And the supposed dupe asks: Can Xylitol cast 1st level spells using the bonus ...


7

The dupe target does care about items. The dupe target asks, without restricting the scope to any one category of features: Are there any ways you have used to mitigate this flaw? This means the question is properly concerned with any game feature that solves the problem of Sunlight Sensitivity, and to quote the Dungeon Master's Guide: Game features ...


6

I think we should leave it as a [house-rules] question That might be surprising, because the ruling they made was also definitely an available official optional rule. But here's the thing: they didn't know that when coming up with their rule. In their universe, not apparently having read Tasha's yet (or at least that section of it), what they created was ...


6

With this specific example, referencing the podcast probably isn't necessary or helpful From the description (I'm not a listener to that podcast), it sounds like what is being described is a worldbuilding element-- a description of the cosmology and inherent operation of the in-game universe. And that description doesn't sound, to me, like it would mesh very ...


5

Including more info is (generally) better than less I don't think there's really any benefit to omitting that information, since it is what prompted your question. If you are specifically looking for deities like the ones in that podcast that inspired your campaign, then it helps to at least mention that. If it ends up being entirely irrelevant, it can ...


5

It's a dupe, you want to Bounty Both questions are asking how to mitigate sunlight sensitivity: that makes your question a duplicate. The answers to the older one do fully include an aspect you are interested in. You'd like to see more than just that, so in these situations where you are asking the same thing but not getting the type or quality of answer you ...


4

I put the change through I went ahead and just updated the duplicate list to include both questions as dupe targets. To me, they both seem like good candidates for being called a duplicate so I went ahead and just added the one you wanted to the list


Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible