Skip to main content
replaced http://rpg.stackexchange.com/ with https://rpg.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

I was wondering if this is just me or if others feel that the remit of rpgse is too narrow and too tightly controlled. I only post generic questions because I don't play D&D and few will know the homebrew systems I play.

So I posted this:

As an experienced GM, what pitfalls should I watch out for?As an experienced GM, what pitfalls should I watch out for?

Because the newbie version of the question was getting some interesting feedback and I was wondering if there were any bad habits I'd gotten into.

The question was closed and now my enthusiasm for the community has waned in an instant.

If we are trying to get out of Beta then we should support a broader range of questions. The question itself wasn't bad and hadn't been asked before. Being quick to close questions is going to put people off.

Is it just me?

I've edited the question to hopefully make it more suitable.

I was wondering if this is just me or if others feel that the remit of rpgse is too narrow and too tightly controlled. I only post generic questions because I don't play D&D and few will know the homebrew systems I play.

So I posted this:

As an experienced GM, what pitfalls should I watch out for?

Because the newbie version of the question was getting some interesting feedback and I was wondering if there were any bad habits I'd gotten into.

The question was closed and now my enthusiasm for the community has waned in an instant.

If we are trying to get out of Beta then we should support a broader range of questions. The question itself wasn't bad and hadn't been asked before. Being quick to close questions is going to put people off.

Is it just me?

I've edited the question to hopefully make it more suitable.

I was wondering if this is just me or if others feel that the remit of rpgse is too narrow and too tightly controlled. I only post generic questions because I don't play D&D and few will know the homebrew systems I play.

So I posted this:

As an experienced GM, what pitfalls should I watch out for?

Because the newbie version of the question was getting some interesting feedback and I was wondering if there were any bad habits I'd gotten into.

The question was closed and now my enthusiasm for the community has waned in an instant.

If we are trying to get out of Beta then we should support a broader range of questions. The question itself wasn't bad and hadn't been asked before. Being quick to close questions is going to put people off.

Is it just me?

I've edited the question to hopefully make it more suitable.

Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackRPG/status/145282163540099073
Source Link
Dr Rob Lang
  • 4.7k
  • 14
  • 8

Asking for advice, looking forward to answers, questions closed, now disillusioned. Is it just me?

I was wondering if this is just me or if others feel that the remit of rpgse is too narrow and too tightly controlled. I only post generic questions because I don't play D&D and few will know the homebrew systems I play.

So I posted this:

As an experienced GM, what pitfalls should I watch out for?

Because the newbie version of the question was getting some interesting feedback and I was wondering if there were any bad habits I'd gotten into.

The question was closed and now my enthusiasm for the community has waned in an instant.

If we are trying to get out of Beta then we should support a broader range of questions. The question itself wasn't bad and hadn't been asked before. Being quick to close questions is going to put people off.

Is it just me?

I've edited the question to hopefully make it more suitable.