Search Results

I feel like this stack is unwelcoming not because there is constructive criticism (which is always welcome, and I encourage) but because there is often condescending and unnecessarily contemptuous att …

No, it sounds really shady. That type of petty and unnecessary intervention undermines the integrity of the website. It drives away intelligent people who would otherwise provide quality questions and …

We should permit opinion questions. They're the only interesting questions, and they're the only questions that matter.

Because it’s unnecessary pedantry. It does not suggest any improvement to the answer, and it does not add any value being left there as is. It seems utterly implausible that anyone reading that questi …

An 'actual problem' is an ambiguous catch all concept that is able to be used to levy any and all criticism without accountability to justifiable argument.

WHY THE QUESTION SHOULD BE OPENED AND ANSWERED "AS IS": "This GM would not allow this at his table." Game and rules should be discussed, commented, analyzed in complete separation from "this GM" or "t …

No, it should stay closed. I don't think there is any reason why "Rules as intended" has gotten any less reason to be closed because: People have used Rules as Intended as an excuse to bend logic and …

How we could do that: We should acknowledge that during the last year, we accumulated an overwhelming majority in favour of "Revert the policy, and treat these edits like any other." So we should trea …

As written, it is off topic. Asking the origin of these terms as they relate to D&D is unavoidably a question of designer's intent. We can list all of the objective historical information about breast …

Statistically, it's a clear enough statement, but to be fair, we should treat it as though it isn't. It isn't fair that people who ask questions about industry-leading product Dungeons & Dragons Fifth …

There is no agreement on many of these topics The thing that has struck me is that there is very little agreement on fundamental things like "what is a policy", "what determines if a policy is valid", …

You are not wrong. In fact, you are right. The purpose of this place on the internet is for people to ask questions and receive answers from experts, answers that are corroborated by research. Looking …

No, the original post lacks strong evidence that explicitly points to a particular system. While the original question does mention several terms that are strongly associated with D&D 5e, it does not …

Let them stand If upvotes can be considered proxies for "I like this answer", "I found this answer useful", or "I agree this is corrected", then removing the answers would be removing well liked, use …

My stance towards the topic: Humans have time when they have time. If they want to use that to further the goal of improving questions/answers, then that is desirable. If users only want to see the ne …